What to say about this show? It’s difficult, because so many things were right, but some were just not. Or rather, they were not-quite-right.
It’s got a lot going for it. It’s pretty true to the Trek legacy. It’s got some really great characters. There were episodes that rivaled the best of the original Trek, and some that were on a par with the worst of that and some of the other series. There were missteps, sure, but doesn’t every first season of every show have some of those?
Overall, it was a pretty strong season. It brings the Trek universe into a more modern type of storytelling. The original series, and most of the follow-ons, were primarily one shot episodes. Everything was neatly and cleanly tied up by the end of the hour. Here, we have a more throughline-based type of story. Although, that’s not quite true, either. There were a few stand-alone episodes, and several arcs of a couple or three episodes that were basically self-contained.
There’s much familiarity here, also. The ship designs, the logos, and some of the equipment are firmly and visually recognizable as Star Trek. The opening credits are a clever collage of familiar ships and objects that are taken apart, redrawn, and rebuilt into new forms that are still familiar. There are familiar characters reimagined and done well, particularly Sarek and Harry Mudd. New characters have perhaps more depth than some of the originals. Michael Burnham is fascinating (No, I’m not sorry!) in her almost split selves. She’s angry and fearful, seeming unable to get past the murder of her parents by Klingons, yet constantly cautioning others against letting past experiences impair present judgements. Her Vulcan upbringing keeps her grounded and prevents the character from becoming too much on any level.
Aliens are mainly represented by the Klingons, who are at their warlike best here, and the Kelpien Saru, who very ably demonstrates the feeling of not belonging as one of the few aliens on the Discovery’s bridge. They ground the series in the Trek foundations of seeing and feeling unseen, and of diversity versus purity of cultures.
So, what was wrong? Well, for one thing, I kept having to remind myself that this Star Trek was set 100 years before TOS. Part of it is the advances in film technology that make TOS and even some of the other series look truly dated, while the new show is glitzy and CGI-filled. It almost makes me wish the decision had been made to make this another future Trek. It wouldn’t take much reworking of the basic idea. It isn’t necessarily a stretch to think there might be a Klingon-Federation split in the future of the Trek universe. And the mycelium drive could have just as easily been a future discovery as a past technology. But that’s me and as the season went on, it was easier to simply enjoy the fancy stuff and work with the story as given. A few episodes relied on tropes and a bit too neat endings, but, again, so did the original series, so that’s not a judgement on this one alone.
At the end, I think it’s a pretty decent show, and hope we get a second season to work out some of the kinks and add one more star to the Trek legacy.
Available now :
After five years away, Kaili is coming home for the ceremony to install her sister as head of the family business. When an old rivalry threatens the family, Kaili and her partner need to use all their skills to save the sisters’ lives. Learn more here
A collection of six short fantasy stories set in varied worlds of magic and mayhem. Learn more here.
A short novelette set in a dystopian Earth after the final environmental collapse. Sam is a genetically engineered chameleon who may hold the key to mankind’s survival. Learn more here.
In a world reeling under the effects of severe climate change, food shortages are common, and arable farmland is scarce. Unscupulous distributors like Beni Oligowma take advantage of the shortages for their own gain. When a promising new technology for growing food even under the harsh conditions is unveiled, grocery store owner Frank is determined to see that everyone is able to benefit from the results, not just the Benis of the world.
Feed My People is a short story, set in a dystopian science fiction world, and is free. Learn more here
Demon hunters Johnny and Cerise travel to the small town of Carroll Fork where they find a demon-possessed thrift store, a sweet old lady who is more than she seems, and an army of underworld inhabitants. Can Johnny and his trusty yo-yo save the town from a devil of a problem?
Five and Daemon, the Yo-Yo Files #1, is a short novelette in an urban fantasy setting, with elements of the supernatural and humor. Learn more here
Things have been quiet. No demonic possessions, no otherworldly intrusions, nothing. And then Lucifer shows up in Johnny’s living room, claiming that two archangels are missing, and something is definitely not right in the heavenly- and other- realms. Saying he has nothing to do with it- this time- he asks Johnny and Cerise to help him find out what’s happening, and who is behind the disappearances. While they are trying to do just that, Lucifer is devilnapped by a larger-than-life serpent. He manages to get a clue to Johnny before he disappears. Johnny and Cerise are left to puzzle out the disappearances and try to find the missing angels. Oh, and stop what could mean the ultimate destruction of pretty much everything.
Snake’s Alive, the Yo-Yo Files #2 is an urban fantasy novelette with elements of the supernatural and humor. Learn more here.
2 thoughts on “Friday (TV) Review: Star Trek: Discovery”
Okay. I’m going to give Discovery more than a five minutes chance. Ta for the review.
It took me a few episodes to decide whether I liked it or not. I still have some reservations, but there’s enough there that I stuck it out. It wasn’t great, but it wasn’t horrendous, either.
Comments are closed.