The following is chock full of spoiling spoilery spoilers. If you have not seen Avengers: Endgame as yet (why????), don’t read if you don’t want to know.
The requested moratorium on Endgame spoilers ended Monday, so we have seen much discussion about the movie. I am going to go into some length here with my review. This is my opinion. You may or may not agree. Comment and we can discuss, but be nice. We can differ and still be friends!
I give it 4 of 5 stars. I truly enjoyed the movie. I had very little trouble with anything while watching and that, to me, is a big plus. If I can suspend disbelief and enjoy a film with few or no moments that pulled me out of it, then the filmmakers have done their job. The questions that come later? Oh, we all have them with many, many films because nothing is perfect. As long as it’s not a drag on the film while its running, I’m fine.
In general, the plot was decent. Lots of fan serving moments, but honestly, didn’t we expect that? Did they all fit in nicely and neatly? Maybe not, but it was cool to see the MCU folks giving the fans some nice gifts in this last movie in the current spate of films.
Some specific character and plot comments:
Hulk: I have to say, the transformation there was bit weird to me. I get the Professor Hulk thing and that was a kind of neat callback to the comics, but it felt off to me. I mean, I get Bruce finally coming to terms with the Hulk being part of him and letting them merge and all. But Bruce has been built up as the quiet guy, the one who doesn’t want or need the spotlight, and here, all of a sudden, he’s posing for selfies and encouraging fans? And what happened to the Hulk? About the only thing left of him was the muscles and green skin.
Hawkeye: Another kind of weird thing to me. Yeah, yeah, Hawkeye turned Ronin and all that. It just felt wrong to me and almost like it should have been in a separate movie. It didn’t fit in this story, IMO. Sure, Clint lost his family and that had to have hit him a crushing blow. But to just turn around and start killing people (okay, yes, bad people but still). Didn’t seem like the Clint of the movies to me.
Captain Marvel: The absent hero. We had all that build up before and after her movie that she was going to be in Endgame and usher in the new Avengers and next phase of the MCU. So, she rescues Tony (with no explanation of how she knew where to go or even that he needed it) and then we don’t even see her until the final battle. I guess I expected a bigger presence.
Cap: Oh, Cap. You have changed so much since you were thawed out, haven’t you? Seems there may be a little gray in all that black and white now. But still determined, strong, willing to do “whatever it takes”. I am glad he and Peggy got that dance he promised her so long ago. Speaking of that, I think that was one of the better time travel moments. He and Peggy being together in an alternate multiverse was a lovely gift. And that scene at the end? The long shot of Cap, all alone, standing against Thanos’ full army? That is the essence of Captain America in one photo. And some awesome cinematography.
Time Travel: Ah, now there’s the rub. Time travel is a tricky thing, and always a problem to deal with. There isn’t a time travel story out there that doesn’t have some inconsistencies and unanswered questions. With that, I thought the use here was decent. The multiverse idea covered a lot of ground, from neatly explaining why going back and killing Thanos as a baby wouldn’t change the present to how to fix the Snap without messing up everything else. It was a decent use of the trope.
Sam is Captain America: Not Bucky? Well, I suppose that would have made sense and I would have been fine with it, but Sam has always been a kind of rock there in the group. He has a good head on his shoulders, and he shares a lot of Steve’s ideals. Bucky? Do we really trust Bucky after his head was so messed with by Hydra? Hmmmm. I think this one could have gone either way, and I’d be okay.
Tony Stark: Well, I didn’t see that coming! I really didn’t. But I think it was a perfect ending for Tony’s time as Iron Man (sorry, RDJ fans!). It was a, I don’t know- a redemption of sorts? After Civil War and the seeming break up of the Avengers, to see Tony and Steve come back to their shared roles as protectors of humanity was one of the good things in this movie. Seeing Tony realize that his father was actually human made me smile. The hug was so full of layers. And the hug he gave Peter? Finally! His end scene with Pepper hit all the feel buttons as well. The callback to the earlier scene in their cabin when she asks him “But would you rest?” Well, we saw the answer to that. And now- “We’re okay. You can rest now.” There were tears. It is okay, Tony. We are okay (mostly). You deserve to rest now.
The two things that bugged me the most:
Thor: I mean, I get that Thor was having problems. He’s changed so much from the brash, full of his own power youngling god we saw in the first Thor movie to a more mature leader who knows what responsibility means. Oh, he never lost the ultra literal side nor his sense of humor, and he was always convinced that no matter what, he would win. He is the God of Thunder and an Odinson, right? And when he couldn’t, no matter how he tried, stop Thanos? To realize that if he’d not been so sure of himself and maybe backed off the ego a little more, he might have “gone for the head”? That had to take a toll on someone like Thor. So, yeah, hiding away in that cabin, drinking beer and eating pizza, and using video games as an escape? Sure, I can see it. And having him pass it off as nothing, as the way things should be, this is me now, is perfectly in line with what is going on in his head. But— The rest of them? To treat him like a joke? They know Thor. They have seen him change over the course of his time with the Avengers. Not one of them recognizes he has a problem and tries to help? All he’s worth now are rolled eyes, sidelong glances, and suppressed laughs? Wow. Way to treat mental illness as a joke. I did not like it.
Black Widow: If you thought poor Natasha got shorted in the other films, geez, this one was the worst. This is a woman with mad fighting skills and an arsenal of fancy tech weapons to drool for, and what? She gets to babysit the comm controls? The most badass thing she did in the whole movie was make a peanut butter sandwich and threaten to throw it at Steve. She didn’t even get to finish the sandwich because Scott stole it. And her ending? Wow. Yeah, sacrifice what you love best for the Stone, okay. But the whole thing felt wrong. Did I want Clint to die? No, of course not. I love Hawkeye. I don’t know if that would have felt better. Maybe they should have gone off the cliff together, not able to choose, and then because of that depth of friendship, both got the Stone. Again, I don’t know. I just know I really would have liked Nat to have made it to the last battle, show off some of her skills, take out a few bad guys, and then maybe not make it out at the end. The way it went, it felt like she was reduced to refrigerator girl, Nobly Sacrificed. For effect. Don’t get me wrong. I cried at seeing her lying at the bottom of that cliff. I just wish she’d been given a little more.
All in all, it was a good movie. There were things I loved. Things I liked. Things I didn’t. There were many tears, both happy and sad. It was a roller coaster ride with only a bit of lag in the second part (which was kind of plot heavy but necessary). The end part was pretty much non-stop thrills. I think it was a good finale for this part of the MCU.
Good-bye, original Avengers. We had some fun, didn’t we? And we can do it all again on DVDs, anytime we want. I look forward to what comes next.
Do you like science fiction and fantasy? I would be very happy if you would check out my books and other stories. You can find more information about them all at the link below. Thank you!